Thursday, October 11, 2007

Of Maverick Minds and Musings


I am writing this post after finally finding the time to read one of my favourite blogs... virtually visiting the mind of another maverick...

www.mediha.blogspot.com specifically, the Melting Pot Bubbling Over post.

It’s been a while since I’ve visited Kak Diha virtually so this is going to be lengthy :-)

The tree of racism and societal divide is slow to come out of the ground but once allowed to grow...it devours everything in its path.

To understand this growing trend i think we must go back a little into history.

Pre Merdeka our country was pretty much segregated thanks to the orang puteh. The Malays were mostly agriculturally inclined but a few elite groups were absorbed into the running of the government (the British recognising that they needed inside men within the majority racial group to quell any potential unrest). The Chinese were businessmen, having come from (at that time) economically booming and British Empire trading, China. The Indians were mostly labourers brought from India (the other colonial seat of power in Asia) to help work the mines, the railways or the plantations... some (like my grandfather) escaped the forced labour of the British but came to Malaysia voluntarily to seek out an independent and more lucrative future for his family.

Years go by; the divide solidifies and becomes even more pronounced...

Enter the people who had the vision of an independent nation. Couple that with the British Empire's gradual withdrawal from its outlying colonies due to both losses sustained during wars and the rising cost of quelling revolt from the conquered. With those two factors working in our favour, Malaysia was birthed.

For a long while our grandparents and parents lived in a world that the different races were solidified by nationalism and the lessons of colonialism. We forgot for a time that we were different races because we shared a common goal and a common enemy (the Empire) The Bumiputera policy at that time sounded feasible and even fair to the Founding Fathers of Malaysia due to the socioeconomic background of each race. I can only lament that the Indians were not more strongly supported. but i guess that we had little or no political capital at that time. But i digress...

Basically, we blended together under these circumstances because we were innocent, trusting, and sad to say a little naive. We had little or no idea what would happen 50 years down the line.

Currently... the average Malaysian has no idea what the colonial times was about.. we are reaping the seeds that we have sown. Things like racially segregative school systems... The Chung Hwas, The San Yuks, The Tamil Schools, The Sekolah Berasrama Penuh, The Sekolah Menengah Agama...Things like the NEP and the Bumiputera policy only reaching the rich and politically connected individuals... Events like May 13th and Kampung Medan events that happened but were not openly discussed only leading to more speculation and unfounded rumours.

People fear and shun what they don't understand...and understanding comes from exposure and education and honest discussion. Truth and Reconciliation Commissions helped South Africa maintain a certain level of societal sanity post apartheid, but in Malaysia we hide from the truth and from open and honest discussion.

Contributing factors like these slowly but surely eroded our nationalistic spirit. Parents of non Malays slowly became more and more disenfranchised and disillusioned by the Malay ruling elite and the parents of the Malays, secure in their created bubble of political advantage became more and more closed off from the other races.

All of us have become xenophobic gradually because of a combination of all these factors

Therefore, if a little girl turns up her nose at her pork eating schoolmate, she is only mimicking what she has seen other people around her do…maybe not her parents or siblings…but her friends and teachers and neighbours.

Xenophobia is not genetic...it’s a virus that is contracted.

I think our country has to seriously ask itself some very hard questions before we can become truly Malaysian. Don't get me wrong... I am a supporter of the Bumiputera policy, even if I do not receive its benefits... but i think that proper implementation, transparency, and accountability of how the policy has been administered is paramount to combat the mounting distrust and disillusionment the non Bumiputeras' feel. I have all confidence that the non Bumiputeras' will be able to understand the simple logic of providing special consideration for the largely economically inferior majority in the country. One only has to look to countries where a minority group became too economically advantaged over another to see how dangerous this trend can be (read civil war and riots).

Affirmative action makes sense...but only if implemented in a transparent and fair manner. Otherwise it breeds too much resentment. Malaysia makes sense...but only when these issues and societal divides are tackled in a long term and positive manner.

Malaysia Boleh? Only if ALL of us Boleh together...

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Xenophobia...a virus...hmmm...maybe.

But to eliminate the need for the above would be to disregard the variable of human evil; our potential for creating hurt (in whatever form) for personal gain. A mans potential for goodness is measured by his capabilities for evil. The absence of the latter leaves the sea without waves.

All reactions has a reason. Xenphobia may provide a society as a form of check and balance to protect a societies culture and norms. Should a society conform to the perception and norms of a solitary alien or should the alien adapt to incoporate to the standards of the surroundings?

Absence of Xenophobia may affect; morals, security, manipulation, societies rules and regulations, patriotism...

Love your neighbour yes...but doesnt mean you should let him in your house without weighing the risk.

Fareez said...

I have to respectfully disagree vehemently with you on this.

Xenophobia is not and will never be necessary to protect anything

There is a HUGE difference between being xenophobic and racist and trying to protect your own culture and morals…and I don’t think that you need to be xenophobic to do that.

That’s like saying that you need to be racist to ensure the advancement of your race.

Being proud of who you are and where you came from should always be the case, but taking it to the extreme like deciding that your own culture is superior than any other, being actively racist, and depriving other individuals of a sense of belonging to a country WE ALL shared in building is something totally different.

But then again you have your own opinion and I respect that. I only ask one thing from you…consider this:

Don’t you think that the “surroundings” may have some very valuable lessons to learn from the “solitary alien”?

Think of the advantages if the “surroundings” respected the “solitary alien’s” rights and the “solitary alien” learns to work together with his “surroundings”

And lastly consider this very important question:

Are we that much different that we need protection from each other?

Peace

Anonymous said...

Hi Fareez,

I think you missed out May 13, 1969. It is the day that most of our Malaysian Baby Boomers will never forget. That's the racial riot that cost the lives of 196 people. It is the worst riot (my opinion) in Malaysia's 50-year history. It seems that if we are not careful, history will repeat itself. Anyway, I’m Rina, Mediha’s friend. I love reading her blogs and I enjoy reading yours too.

Anonymous said...

Okay,
I noticed that you have included May 13th and Kampung Medan event. Well, there goes my Credibility! :)

Anonymous said...

Someone's blog needs an UPDATE!!

Afifah said...

update!

Fareez said...

Rina

Welcome! :-) its good to hear that someone enjoys reading my particular brand of idiocy...

hope to hear more from you in other posts InsyaAllah

Lin
Hi dear!! i know i know... been busy la. Trying to make something out of myself is tiring you know.

Afifah
hek eleh budak ni

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.